I suppose this could be done with a pot roast, but there are a couple of things going for lamb shanks as the prime ingredient:
- lamb is much less a part of the feedlot culture than beef.
- all the bone & connective tissue releases gelatin, which gives the gravy body.
- there’s nothing quite like a whole shank for presentation.
Other than the lamb shanks, the ingredients are pretty easy to find. The trickiest thing may be finding a pot (or pots) to cook them in. You want the lamb to braise in a single layer, in a closed pot with a tight lid, and it’s much easier to manage if this pot can also be used to saute the ingredients, meaning it’s got a heavy bottom as well. Pots like this are expensive. If you don’t have one, saute in a frying pan and transfer the ingredients to a roasting pan, and cook in the oven. In that case, preheat the oven to 325.
Ingredients (for six):
- 6 lamb shanks
- olive oil
- 2 celery stalks, chopped
- 1 large onion, chopped
- 1 large carrot, chopped
- 6 large garlic cloves, chopped
- 3 or more drained canned anchovies – I use about 6
- 2 cinnamon sticks
- 2 bay leaves
- a couple sprigs of fresh thyme (or substitute dried, or a big pinch of oregano)
- 6Â juniper berries (or substitute a shot of gin)
- dash ground nutmeg
- 2 tbs. or more tomato paste – I’ve used a whole (small) can to no ill effect
- 1 bottle red wine
- 1 quart chicken or beef broth
- salt & pepper to taste
Note: none of these ingredients needs to be precisely measured. In particular, you can safely substitute your favorite herbs if you don’t have thyme. Most of the flavorings fade into the background, just making the dish more complex without necessarily being recognizable as themselves, so you can probably omit one or two, or change the proportions, without disrupting the dish. The exception is the cinnamon, which is quite assertive, and really dominates the dish. I suppose you could cut it back, but I think the dish would lose some of its identity.
Salt the lamb shanks, and saute in some olive oil to brown, about 10 minutes max per batch. You can do a few at a time if your pan is small. Set aside.
Add celery, onion, carrot, garlic, & anchovies to the pot, and saute gently (“sweat”) until the vegetables begin to soften, about 15 minutes. Add herbs & spices & saute a few minutes longer. Add the tomato paste, wine, and broth, bring to a boil. Boil for a few minutes to get rid of the alcohol.
If you’ve been sauteing in the same pot you’ll use to finish the dish, add the lamb shanks, cover, and reduce heat until the dish is just simmering. You can finish the dish on top of the stove.
If you’re finishing the dish in the oven, put the lamb shanks & the sauce into the roasting pan, cover, and put into the pre-heated oven.
In either case, you want the liquid in the dish to be simmering, not boiling madly away. Adjust the heat accordingly. Every 1/2 an hour or so, turn the lamb shanks & baste, and after about 2 hours, begin to check for doneness.
This is the crux of the dish: cooking it long enough, but not too long. At first, the meat will seem raw. Then, it will look cooked, but it will require considerable effort, and a knife, to cut off a piece. Eventually, the meat will begin to separate along the natural muscle boundaries, and will pull off the bone with increasing ease. Finally, the meat will fall off the bone entirely, and will break up into shreds (like pulled pork).
You want to stop cooking at the second-to-last stage above, when the meat is still attached to the bone, but separates fairly easily. Depending on the size of the shanks, and whether you cook on top of the stove or in the oven, it will take between 2 and 3 hours to reach this stage.
Another point to watch is the salt. You need to add some salt at the beginning, so that the lamb will absorb some of it. But you should leave the dish seemingly undersalted, because the next step (reducing the stock) will concentrate the salt as well as all the other flavors. Also, if you use regular salted chicken or beef stock, you may not want to add any additional salt till the end, but some of the organic stocks are unsalted, and in that case I’d add a little salt at the beginning.
Once the lamb is done, transfer it to another container (a platter if you’re going to serve it immediately). If necessary, reduce the stock to concentrate it until it is fairly thick. Process the stock through a food mill (my preference), a blender, or a food processor, or force it through a sieve or collander. Adjust seasonings & reduce further if necessary. Pour over the lamb shanks.
The dish may be prepared ahead, and reheated.
This dish is a great foil for an old red wine. Almost any older red will do: Chateauneuf, Barolo, Bordeaux. It is hard to beat a 10 year old Vosne-Romanee or Oregon Pinot. If you don’t have a cellar, a Rioja Gran Riserva is probably your best bet.
I recently tried this with boneless short ribs, largely because I can find these regularly at Costco. This particular cut was OK but perhaps a little too lean – next time I’ll look for bone-in. And even though I cut the meat into smallish pieces (about 2″x2″x3″), it took a good 3 hours to reach the not-quite-falling-apart stage. For 3 pounds of boneless ribs, I needed a bit more than half the liquid called for in the recipe.
Filed under:
Uncategorized by pmasters